Quibble
(1) Negotiation about the trivial.
(2) Noting the use of words which—while substantially true—mislead, evade or conceal the main issue.
Example headline in The Times: “The Thirsty £1½m Car That Needs Only Water”.Q1 In fact, the car needs hydrogen, which is produced from water by the application of large quantities of power, which has to be supplied by oil, gas, hydropower or some other energy source: hydrogen does not actually reduce the quantity of fuel needed to drive cars—in fact, it increases it.Q2
As the article eventually explains, the original energy source in this particular case is hydropower, so technically the headline is correct, but the super-confident hint—that, instead of filling up the cars of the future with petrol we will just add water (thanks to amazing new technologies)—is of course misleading. It reinforces the error that all we need in order to cope with the energy peak is a few clever technical fixes.
The quibble can build giant structures of falsehood, without ever requiring the architect to tell a lie.
Related entries:
Distraction, Special Pleading.
« Back to List of Entries